Commencement Matter: 22 June 2016

I raised the following matter during commencement matter on 22 June 2016

"The need for the Minister for Health to give assurances to the people of Roscommon that the Primary Care Centre in Monksland will remain under the HSE West and not be moved under any circumstance to the control of HSE (Community Health Organisation CHO8) which serves counties Laois, Offaly, Longford, Westmeath, Louth and Meath and that he assures the people of Roscommon that this is not another attack on the integrity of the County of Roscommon"

Response from Minister of State Sean Canney TD (On behalf of Minister for Health, Simon Harris TD - See link below "No decision has been made to transfer the

Follow Eugene on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/eugene.murphy.39?fref=ts


​

I oppose plans to change a county boundary that would put 12pc of Roscommon people into Westmeath.sign the petition


​Sign the Petition  http://bit.ly/1JWTPGZ



The following email will be sent to submissions@westmeathcoco.ie
For the attention of Lourda Giles, Athlone Boundary Review, Secretariat, Westmeath Co Council.
Date: 19/01/16
Re: Athlone Boundary Review
Dear Chairperson
I object to the proposal to shift any part of County Roscommon into County Westmeath because:
1) Identity – this proposal would affect my identity.
I am proud of my Roscommon links and wish to maintain pride in this identity. What gives authority to any politician or public servant to interfere with my identity in this manner. I do not want the County I identify with weakened. Any such boundary change would also affect the identities of the children who are growing up in this area and identify themselves as Roscommon People.
2) Loss of strength of Co Roscommon.
If Roscommon loses the Area of Interest or any part of it and its population, it will be a weakened County with less bargaining power when bidding for funds. In the future Roscommon would be entitled to less in any process based on population.
The Area of Interest and Monksland/Bealnamullia represents the second largest town in Co Roscommon (after Roscommon Town) and has the potential for further community and industrial growth. The impact of the loss of its second largest town on the remainder of the County would be devastating and leave the County weakened with fewer people and less revenue capacity. What reasons are there for a Government to inflict such a retrograde change upon Co Roscommon.
3) County Roscommon will lose the significant revenues it collected in the Area.
The rents and rates collected by Roscommon Co Council in the affected area will be lost to the County. These comprise a significant proportion of its own independent revenue stream. Any temporary compensation arrangement that might be introduced will be short lived.
Not only will Roscommon be left without the existing revenue streams but it will also lose out on the continued growth potential of the area. There will be no compensation for any such future losses. Ultimately all revenues from the Area will go to the benefit of Co Westmeath along with any revenues from the future growth of Monksland. I consider that this will be a devastating loss to Roscommon County all the more so when one considers that Co Roscommon has invested heavily in the infrastructure and people of the area over the past number of years.
4) Many Sporting and Cultural Organisations will lose out.
Whereas it is noted that the Boundary Committee has stated that ‘The application of any changes to the administrative boundaries by sporting or other cultural bodies would be a matter for the bodies themselves’ – it is considered that this statement is a pre-judgement of the consultation process. Government should not pre-judge a consultation process. I also consider that any proposed change in the County Boundary would significantly affect the viability of and or reduce the effectiveness of
clubs and organisations thus weakening the Social fabric of life in the remainder of County Roscommon.
5) Many Government Services to County Roscommon will lose out.
Allocations for services to Co Roscommon will be diminished. Any future rationalisation of services will threaten the existing services in Monksland such as the Primary Care Unit.
6) Roscommon Co Council has Invested Significantly in the Area.
When I look at what Roscommon Co Council has done for the ‘Area of Interest’ I see that they have provided state of the art water and sewage treatment, new safer roads, children’s play areas, has purchased land in advance for a new national school, provided land for industry, provided a community centre, sports pitches with modern dressing rooms, extended the local cemetery and provided many other day to day requirements for a vibrant community life. Roscommon Co Council has truly implemented the principles of ‘Putting People First’ even before it was adopted as a policy framework
On the contrary when I look at what has happened to the West side of Athlone since it was moved in to County Westmeath I see that that area has not been nurtured or treated well under Westmeath Co Council jurisdiction. Once a thriving part of Athlone Town CSO statistics now show that it is the most deprived area of County Westmeath.
7) Co-operation between Co Roscommon and Co Westmeath.
There is a very high level of co-operation between the two counties at present. This includes the
Rapid Programme, the Emergency & Fire Service, Road Maintenance, Planning and Water Services, Rural Transport. Where is the evidence to show that the existing arrangements are not working or need to be addressed? Where is the evidence to show that an alteration in the Boundary is necessary? Where has such argument been set out in a Government consultative paper for public comment?
If the Minster thinks that service provision needs to be improved why not establish joint working groups of officials between the two authorities on a statutory basis to implement whatever element he considers appropriate. Why does he consider the blunt tool of a County boundary change will achieve the desired outcome?
8) There is a Lack of Democracy in this process.
The process being adopted to assess and ultimately effect this change is not democratic. The
1991 Act vests the final say in this matter with the Minister for the Environment Community & Local Government. Why not have a referendum amongst the affected people and ask them if they wish to be transferred in to County Westmeath? Why has the Minister not at least enacted the provisions of the 2001 Act which would require him to put the matter before both houses of the Oireachtas?
9) Loss of Employment and Economic Performance.
I believe a boundary change will hinder the generation of Employment in the Area. To support
this view just look at what happened to the west side of Athlone since it was taken over by Co
Westmeath in 1899. Connaught Street then the main street of Athlone has since been let run down. The only infrastructure provided has been a largely unsuccessful housing development at the Batteries. Any significant business has been moved and the Army Barracks has been downgraded – all without any fight being made by Westmeath Co Council.
10) Community.
In Monksland, Bealnamullia and Drum area there is an existing thriving Community with many busy social and community active organisations. The Area also has a thriving business Community. These did not happen by accident but have grown through bottom up people driven actions which have been carefully facilitated and nurtured by Roscommon Co Council.
Notwithstanding the discouragement to raising Community Club/Organisation boundary issues contained in the Public Advertisement placed on 1st December 2015 I consider that this is a vital community issue and I object to that attempt to limit my submission in this regard. I beg to differ with your suggestion that such matters are for the organisations alone. A boundary change will have significant effects on many clubs and organisations and would have the potential to destroy the dynamics and feeling of ownership over such organisations.
11) Strengths of Existing Arrangement.
The first evidence of the strength of the existing arrangement is to cite the thriving local social and business communities in Monksland, Bealnamullia and Drum. Then compare this with the west side of Athlone which when examined under CSO deprivation indices has not thrived under Westmeath administration.
Roscommon Co Council has ensured that the area could develop and thrive through the provision of services and by empowering the Local community to take actions on its own behalf and grow to become the second largest town in the County.
Yours Sincerely,
Senator Terry Leyden, Castlecoote, Roscommon
Phone: 0906626422
Email: terry.leyden@oireachtas.ie

Senator Terry Leyden:   It is very difficult to continue as usual in ordinary business when we are dealing with a tragedy such as that which happened in Berkeley in California. All I can say is that we hope those who are injured will make a recovery and that we extend our deepest sympathies to the families and friends of the six young people who have died. I thank the emergency services in America, which have been very effective. The tragedy highlights the trust we place in our architects and designers to ensure that when they build, they do so securely. While an inquiry is under way at the moment, it seems to be very difficult to extend buildings and verandas with timber. I am rather surprised at the lack of quality building in that area. Those young people would have had complete faith in the security of a building of that nature and would not have thought twice about being out there. It is a tragedy and a shame that standards are not as high in America as one would expect.

  I propose to amend the Order of Business to include No. 16 on the Order Paper, a motion that Seanad Éireann oppose the closure of the Rosalie unit in County Roscommon, which cares for psychiatric patients, including those with Alzheimer's disease and dementia. The matter was raised at a public meeting last Thursday night. It is a very serious situation which affects 23 patients, who are mostly psychiatric patients but include those with Alzheimer's disease and dementia, and who were previously patients of the closed St. Patrick's hospital in Castlerea. There is tremendous support for the patients and residents of what is their home and a great deal of attention is being given to them. Very significant information was provided at the meeting by Mr. Liam Walsh, whose mother, Breda, is a resident. He explained clearly how upset everyone is that they will lose their home. It is frankly an eviction by the HSE without any care or consideration. The only hope is in the ministerial responsibility which attaches to the Minister of State, Deputy Kathleen Lynch. I appeal to her, through Senator John Kelly, who I understand is agreeable that the motion be moved today, to attend the House today or tomorrow to outline the situation and to halt the eviction of these 23 people. It is a form of euthanasia to do what the HSE is doing. It is a most uncaring example of what the HSE is responsible for. At the end of the day, the Minister of State has ministerial responsibility in this regard. I ask the Leader of the House to accede to the proposal to amend the Order of Business.

See Motion: http://oireachtasdebates.oireachtas.ie/debates%20authoring/DebatesWebPack.nsf/takes/seanad2015061700002?opendocument&highlight=Rosalie

Mental Health Services: 


Motion Senator Terry Leyden:   I move:

That Seanad Éireann opposes the closure of the Rosalie Unit in Castlerea, County Roscommon, which cares for psychiatric patients including those with Alzheimer’s and dementia.

Senator Mary M. White:   I second the motion.

  Question put and agreed to.

Senator Terry Leyden: "That Seanad Éireann opposes the closure of the Rosalie unit in Castlerea, County Roscommon, which cares for psychiatric patients including those with Alzheimer's and dementia."

I ask the Deputy Leader to provide time for a debate today, otherwise, with my colleagues, we intend to move the motion for debate.  The situation is that the matter has been raised by people like Councillor Paschal Fitzmaurice, Councillor Orla Leyden, Councillor Nigel Dineen and other councillors. Others involved include Dr. Greg Kelly and Dr. Charles Byrne, who is the chief psychiatrist in County Roscommon. He has expressed his concerns in today's local newspapers. He is a consultant psychiatrist and he has strongly criticised the plans to close the Rosalie unit at Áras Naomh Caolinn in Castlerea.


An Cathaoirleach:   We are not having a debate on that.

Senator Terry Leyden:   He has called for the decision to be reversed. What is happening down there is absolutely elder abuse. The 25 patients are being thrown to the wind without any concern whatsoever just because the HSE wants to cut costs. The Minister of State, Deputy Kathleen Lynch, is absolutely not carrying out her duties.

  I am calling on Senator Kelly to use his influence in the Labour parliamentary party to reverse this decision, which is against the interests of patients in County Roscommon. We are going to continue to move this issue in this House. We are going to get a situation where there will be a vote in this House. We will call on Senator Kelly to vote against the closure of the Rosalie unit in Castlerea, County Roscommon, rather than being on radio talking about this. Deputies Frank Feighan and Denis Naughten and all the other Deputies have no influence. I want them all involved on this issue to ensure we have no further downgrading of medical services in County Roscommon.


Link to Debate: 

http://oireachtasdebates.oireachtas.ie/debates%20authoring/DebatesWebPack.nsf/takes/seanad2015061100002?opendocument&highlight=Rosalie

Remarks by Michael Martin TD
http://www.fiannafail.ie/news/entry/11556/

News Report from RTE
http://www.rte.ie/news/player/2014/0915/20649061-fianna-fail-hold-think-in-in-roscommon/

Senator Terry Leyden has expressed his sympathy to Kathleen Reynolds and family & to brother Jim Reynolds & family on death of Albert Reynolds R.I.P.former T.D.& Taoiseach.I was elected with Albert in 1977 until 1992.

He achieved a great deal in his political career especially the Peace process & Downing Street Agreement of Dec.1993.May he rest in peace.

We were honoured that Deputy Sean Fleming T.D., Laois/Offaly paid us a visit over the weekend.

I attended the AGM of Roscommon Ogra on 08 September 2012 in the Abbey Hotel, Roscommon. Congratulations to the 
Incoming committee of Roscommon Ógra Fianna Fáil, I look forward to working closely with Roscommon Ogra in my capacity as the only FF member of the Oireachtas for Roscommon.

Chairperson: David Keane
Vice Chairperson: Seán Óg Higgins
Secretary: Gárbh Madigan
Co- Treasurer: Mairéad Mulry
Co- Treasurer: Raymond Keane
PRO/Membership: Michelle Meally